The following will apply when evaluating submitted work for publication.
Based on your assessment of the validity of the manuscript, what would you advise be the next step?
In addition, we ask you gauge the relative merits of this work and its potential newsworthiness (note this is for manuscript which you recommend be published or revised). This allows us to identify outstanding work and issue press releases. Simply state whether you think this work is
The whole review should then be submitted as a single file. Note that this is the version the author will receive
If you wish to make additional, private, comments to the editor, you may do so when uploading the review through the our email firstname.lastname@example.org